Keeping Secrets Doesn't Build Tension

One of the D&D campaigns I'm running is a called Skyfell. We meet once a month and this past weekend was the big day! 

I enjoy being a dungeon master. It's not just because it's an outlet for my tendency to indulge in world building. I enjoy developing a challenge and partaking in the cooperative storytelling that emerges as a group of people work together to overcome that challenge. When everything works out, it feels as though all is right in the universe.

A blind spot of mine as a DM, however, is not giving enough clues regarding the mysteries the PCs must solve. I provide plenty of NPCs to interact with but when the players start interrogating them I usually fail to disclose the important bits even if the players are asking the right questions. I think part of it is that I forget to drop the info; I'm caught up in the moment. Part of it is lack of prep; I have failed to work out exactly what each of the NPCs knows. Part of it is that I have a tendency to feel that keeping information away from the players is more interesting; intellectually I understand that it is not. 

I was guilty of that last mistake during last month's session of Skyfell. This did not harm the PCs but it did make them scratch their heads more than they should have had to do. I didn't want to make that same mistake again. When we met again over the week end I forced myself to slow down the interactions and contemplate the dialog before delivering it. This worked well. The stream of clues itself actually built the tension I was hoping for. I didn't execute as well as I had hoped but I did at least convey most of what I wanted to.
I now know that when I'm developing an arc I need to include the information each of the NPCs knows, how much of that information they are willing to give away, and what they are willing to part with for the right price. Doing so will definitely generate role playing opportunities and enrich the overall story. It'll make the arc more fun too.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Follow me on one of these fine social media platforms:
Instagram: @hokumsean
Spotify: @hokumsean
Twitch: @hokumsean
Twitter: @hokumsean
Tumblr @hokumsean

Stop by my YouTube channel "Ovens and Dragons" and partake in the exciting world of cooking for gamers.

Also, check out my DMsGuild offerings:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Open Sky Encounters

Image
In Session 12 of my Dungeons and Dragons home-brew campaign Skyfell the player characters acquired an airship. I've already written up quite a few rules regarding airships and the nature of air travel in Skyfell (see my Airships post ). That was good enough to explain a bit about ships for earlier sessions. I'm assuming, however, that the characters will be sailing the open skies more frequently now. That's the sort of freedom owning an airship grants. There is, of course, a potential for encountering new locales and new creatures as they travel. So, I put together this set of rules for random encounters in the Open Skies. Like all the material regarding Skyfell on this blog, I've posted this for my players. These rules will likely change as we use them in the campaign. That said, feel free to use and adapt for your own campaign. Also, if you’re interested, I have assembled a couple playlists of session music specifically for sailing the open skies. There is one su
Read more

5e Conversion: Fallout Nuka-Cola

Image
  5e Conversion: Fallout's Nuka-Cola As there appears to be no end to my obsession with the Appalachia wasteland, I of course, must provide another conversion for  Fallout 76  into the  Dungeons and Dragons  setting. This time around, I want to tackle that most refreshing of novelty beverages, Nuka-Cola.  In case you don't know, the  Fallout  setting has a ubiquitous soda called Nuka-Cola that comes in convenient, rocket-shaped bottles. The standard variety is simply a refreshing way to hydrate and restore yourself while out and about braving the dangers of the wasteland. There are, however, several other specialty flavors that provide a wide range of other benefits. As with the chems, I feel that in a Dungeons and Dragons setting, Nuka-Cola would be a kind of potion, perhaps developed by some enterprising gnome as a way to differentiate his or her magical offerings from all the other potions that clutter up the adventuring market. I mean, who else but a gnome would think to u
Read more

5e Conversion : The Grinch

Image
5e: The Grinch The holiday season is upon us and once again my Dungeons and Dragons mind turns to Christmas with an unreasoning need to mash up the two. To that end, I bring you The Grinch stat block (as I imagine it). This stat block is based on the 2000 live-action movie How the Grinch Stole Christmas starring Jim Carrey. For roleplaying tips, watch the movie. Let me know if you use this stat block and how it worked out. Merry Christmas. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Follow me on one of these fine social media platforms: Instagram : @hokumsean Spotify : @hokumsean Twitch : @hokumsean Twitter : @hokumsean Tumblr  @hokumsean Stop by my YouTube channel " Ovens and Dragons " and partake in the exciting world of cooking for gamers. Also, check out my DMsGuild offerings: Epic Gnomish Inventing Rules supplement for creating gadgets. Gnome Concept Packages 1 Collection of gnome-related backgrounds, feats, magic items, and m
Read more